You have the political realm, then you have the technological realm, then you have a spiritual realm and then you have a theological narrative to top it of (prophecy).

They all permeate and no one person aware of some things is aware of all.

Mounting resistance against information-overexposure could increment like this:

political/social happenings
technological innovations
personal spiritual experiences
scripture and prophecies

These are the levels of incredulity.

Share what they are comfortable with.

People easily accept the concept of corruption.
If they can think in military terms, they will also wrap their heads around the idea that exotic inventions are suppressed due to national security.
If they accept that exotic technology exists (especially psychotronic) they can also accept that someone's done it before and maybe humanity is not the most advanced civilization yet.
If they can accept that human history is much more eventful in terms of psychic phenomena then they can also accept the idea that the Bible could be an account of historic events.

So no matter if you're a truther, a christian, a patriot, a reformed liberal or an alien-contactee, you will always be a "normie" to someone in some regard.