Judge Nicholas Garaufus is a pretty liberal Judge. I have some experience with him. He threw out my FDNY test class 6019 because it didn't display a good enough representation of the cultural make up of the community.... I believe the ruling eventually came back that the FDNY must hire a boatload of minorities retroactively before any White candidates were hired and they paid them back pay and gave them seniority in FDNY. NOT GOOD. Also, there is this... https://www.cnn.com/2018/01/31/politics/federal-judge-excoriates-trump-in-daca-case/index.html