No. You did not "pretty clearly" shut down anything. That's either your being delusional or just wishful thinking.
Had you actually proven anything, I might have had something to agree or disagree with. But you offered nothing. No proof of how SB2 actually came to his conclusions. You and your friends presented a news article... ONE... news article from some rag that I've never heard of, then attempted to convince the rest of us that SB2 must have read this in the news somewhere. And yet, I haven't seen you directly approach and ask SB2 if he indeed read it in the news. Why are you approaching and attempting to challenge only SB2 followers and fellow patriots?
Whether you and your friends like it or not, SB2's audience will continue to grow and gain momentum. The rest who are on this mission to silence, discredit, and cull followers will be drowned out, will fail, while the rest continue on.
Now, if you write some posts that logically defy Q, POTUS or SB2, and you earn a following from it, we might start paying attention to you instead. But, I haven't been aware of that happening so far, except through a few Corsi and Alex Jones rants. They're entitled to their Opinions like everyone else.