September 5, 1958 was a FRIDAY
But that's OK, your newspaper clipping says Sept 3rd.
As to Anthony Fauci, aged 26 in 1958
It clearly is not the guy who we watch on TV
Born in 1940.
Fauci is not that uncommon of a surname in NY
and Anthony is a very common boys name among Italians.
Check the genealogy for Anthony Fauci and you will find a lot of them in the USA.
P.S. in 1958 they had these things called PHONEBOOKS and if you want to know where someone lived, you just looked in the book.
So how come you are guessing who this Fauci guy is, when you could have just checked the 1958 phonebook for the neighborhood?
Guess what? The English word virgin simply meant unmarried at the time it was written in the first English bible. It was a synonym for maiden.
Virgin was the Norman French word and maiden was the Anglo-saxon one.