Israel lobby pressures Univ of Toronto to rescind scholar hire
The University of Toronto has allegedly rescinded a job offer to a prominent human rights scholar after a sitting Canadian tax court judge complained about her research on Palestinian rights.
Justice David Spiro is a former board member of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, the premier Zionist organization in Canada.
He is also a major donor to the university.
.@ValentinaAzarov is scary smart, does brilliant work, and unquestionably deserved the job. I am so angry this happened to her. But separately—it sends a deeply troubling message that doing much-needed human rights work on Palestine will cost you. @UTLaw needs to make this right. https://t.co/cxjrbM7FsX
— Bassam Khawaja (@Bassam_Khawaja) September 17, 2020
More than 1,400 human rights advocates, scholars and lawyers say that this is blatant censorship, a violation of academic freedom and dangerous acquiescence to a donor’s political agenda.
The letter calls on the university to reinstate the professor and investigate the judge’s conduct.
The university offered professor Valentina Azarova, a human rights scholar who has written about Israel’s violations of international law, to head the law school’s International Human Rights Program on 11 August.
She accepted the offer on 19 August, according to The Globe and Mail and members of the hiring committee.
In early September, the law school’s dean, Edward Iacobucci, killed the job offer and suspended the search for the human rights program’s director indefinitely.
Iacobucci and the university then denied that Azarova was hired in the first place. “We can confirm that no offer of employment was made to any candidate, and therefore, no offer was revoked,” the administration stated, adding that the faculty of the law school “canceled the search.”
But email records refute such claims.
Outraged to hear that @UTLaw dean Edward Iacobucci rescinded an offer to the brilliant @ValentinaAzarov—bowing to donor pressure over her excellent Israel/Palestine work. She was the unanimous pick of the hiring panel. What a scandal. https://t.co/9KRkdCF1wZ
— Bassam Khawaja (@Bassam_Khawaja) September 17, 2020
10. This characterization is directly contradicted by the evidence. Our second (and final) round of interviews took place on Jul 30, after which the hiring committee settled on a unanimous consensus that Valentina was the top choice. We set out immediately to review references: pic.twitter.com/Rs3q2ekuCU
— Vincent Wong (@InitialVW) September 19, 2020
Protesting the dean’s actions, the chair of the hiring committee, law professor Audrey Macklin, and the entire three-member advisory board resigned, as did the law school’s research associate Vincent Wong.
I did not want to resign given ongoing projects on media freedom, protest rights, and migrant rights I was working on, but when it became clear the admin would not reverse course on their disqualification of @ValentinaAzarov, our consensus candidate, there was little choice.
https://electronicintifada.net/blogs/nora-barrows-friedman/israel-lobby-pressures-univ-toronto-rescind-scholar-hire?utm_source=EI+readers&utm_campaign=66bb7af365-RSS_EMAIL_CAMPAIGN&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_e802a7602d-66bb7af365-290660781