Lesley Stahl’s damning Trump anecdote goes viral, but did it actually happen?
Journalists are often told that, “If your mother says she loves you, check it out.”
Members of the press would do well to take this advice seriously, especially as our industry is deeply distrusted by the public.
That is, reporters would be wise to do the opposite of what so many did this week after CBS News’s Leslie Stahl revealed a supposedly shocking anecdote about President Trump.
In an interview Monday with PBS’s Judy Woodruff, Stahl claimed she asked the president in a “semiprivate” meeting in November 2016 why he attacks the press.
“I said, ‘You know, that is getting tired. Why are you doing this? You’re doing it over and over and it’s boring and it’s time to end that. You know, you’ve won the nomination. Why do you keep hammering at this?'” she started.
“You know why I do it?” Trump responded, according to the "60 Minutes" host. “I do it to discredit you all and demean you all, so when you write negative stories about me no one will believe you.”
If Trump said this, there’s no defending it. It’d be a despicable act of manipulation. If Trump said this, it would show just how cynical he really is.
But that’s a big “if.” Do we have any reasons not to believe it? Sure. For example, why is she only telling this story now, 17 months after the conversation allegedly took place? And does she have the rest of this interview?
Can she authenticate any of this story? It’s not that far-fetched a thing for Trump to say (well, the “demean” part is a bit much), but we need something more than hearsay for a claim of this size.
At least, you’d hope reporters would ask for some sort of proof. Many didn’t Tuesday.
“This is terrifying,” said NBC News affiliate reporter William Pitts.
“Trump tells [Lesley Stahl] he demeans the press so no one will believe negative stories about him. Well, alrighty then,” said CNBC’s Christina Wilkie.
Upworthy’s Parker Molloy added, “It’s obvious this is what he’s doing, but still kind of amazing that he’d say it out loud.”
The Intercept Managing Editor Charlotte Greensit added, “This is what it ALL boils down to with this President.”
To be fair, not everyone in the news media took her story at face value, but the skeptics were in the minority as far as public comments are concerned.
All too often, it seems that members of the press are happy to accept whatever they hear so long as it reflects poorly on a given target. They’re even happier to make the claim go viral.
It doesn’t matter if the claim has been vetted or not. It doesn’t even matter if the claim raises more questions about the storyteller. All that matters is that it does the intended damage.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/lesley-stahls-damning-trump-anecdote-goes-viral-but-did-it-actually-happen