Good post. I was about to post essentially the same thing. Some compromises are made to make his information as interesting and reach the largest audience possible so I can understand the criticism. He takes his research as far down the rabbit hole as you can possibly go and makes some pretty bold claims, but he always presents this stuff as just a working theory. Furthermore he always cites a ton of facts in his books and most of his interpretations of them are logical.
His most important contribution to the Great Awakening is making it clear to his readers that he doesn't see the idea of a cabal as theory, and he has been predicting this type movement for years. He has also been following things like the sealed indictments, Wikileaks, Vegas, and Saudi Arabia on his blog and I can't wait for his next book to incorporate all of this. If you are at all interested in the spiritual component of the Great Awakening that Q has made clear is important but has not really explained, then he is a great author to read.
Also, check out my thread where I go through some of his research. In all of the books I have read by him he goes through the signs that we are a critical moment in human history (with a focus on the unprecedented changes in the Schumann resonance over the past few days), and link it to some ancient prophecies Wilcock collected that describe a change in the world that is nearly identical to the Great Awakening.