Memefag here who had a flash of inspiration. Forgive me if this seems WAY out there on the identity of Hussein's gay pal.
But… there ARE some similarities… See Pics. Eyebrows, dimpled chin. Nose, depending on the angle… Eyes, depending on the angle and make-up. It all seems to be there.
There's a lazy-eye drift in each photo, more pronounced in Michele's second pic. You can still see it in the more posed first pic.
Also, the chin dimple is evident in the man and the posed Michele pic.
The eyebrows on the man stary from underneath and arc over the brow. The second Michele pic perfectly illustrates the same structure.