Fifteen Republican state finance chiefs are probing whether directors of BlackRock mutual funds are sufficiently independent of the giant asset manager, questioning their investment moves on China, coal, and climate change
trib.al/Qcd0EOS
https://twitter.com/mailonline/status/1689097960594845696
Fifteen Republican state finance chiefs are probing whether directors of BlackRock mutual funds are sufficiently independent of the giant asset manager, questioning their investment moves on China, coal, and climate change.
The group has raised concerns in a letter about the governance of mutual funds as part of a broader push against the growing clout of environmental, social and governance (ESG) values in business.
Their letter, dated August 2 and obtained by DailyMail.com this week, was addressed to ten members of BlackRock's Fixed-Income Board of Directors, which oversees the group's closed-end mutual funds.
BlackRock says board members act in the best interests of all fund shareholders.
'We are concerned about whether your board is sufficiently independent to supervise BlackRock's performance as an investment adviser,' says the letter.
'Most of you are either employed by BlackRock or hold additional positions as board members of publicly traded companies in which BlackRock owns a sizeable share.'
The GOP letter says 'these personal entanglements' could 'easily impair a director's ability to exercise independent judgment when reviewing possible misconduct by BlackRock.'
The financial officers raise concerns about investment choices 'in response to outside pressure from large institutional clients' that help fight climate change but don't make investors richer.
Fund managers pulled out of coal, which causes more carbon pollution than other energy sources, meaning investors missed out on an 'enormous rise in share prices within the coal industry,' the letter says.
Meanwhile, BlackRock has 'poured billions of dollars into China' as the first foreign firm allowed to operate there, even though this created 'potential financial risks to its clients,' the letter said.
This also hurt the 'national security interests of the US and other democracies,' says the letter.
Critics have raised similar issues in the past about whether well-paid mutual fund directors are positioned to speak up.
The GOP finance chiefs apply that concern in the context of stances BlackRock has taken on ESG issues, such as a request for portfolio companies to account for climate change.
They ask for responses to guide their states on whether to invest in BlackRock funds.
The document follows up on last month's letter from 15 Republican state attorneys general to the same directors, asking about financial relationships that could undermine their independence.
BlackRock's chief spokesman Chris Van Es confirmed the letter had been sent to the directors.