April 3, 2024
Young Thug Fights To Exclude Rap Lyrics From Trial After GA Supreme Court Ruling
Grammy-winning hip-hop artist Young Thug, alongside his co-defendant Shannon Stillwell, has challenged the use of lyrics and music videos as evidence in their trial for gang-related crimes, drawing on a recent Georgia Supreme Court ruling, according to Courthouse News. In November 2023, Fulton County Chief Judge Ural Glanville permitted 17 sets of lyrics as evidence, but Young Thug moved to strike this decision following a March ruling where the court reversed a murder conviction due to unfair prejudice from a rap video.
Young Thug's attorney, Brian Steel, argued that lyrics like "I never killed anybody, but I got something to do with that body," ” which Young Thug rapped on the 2018 track “Anybody” featuring Nicki Minaj, lack contextual relevance and could mislead the jury.
The line provided no details or nexus in association with a certain crime, Steel argued, and assuming the statements amounted to an admission — and presenting them out of context — could "horrify" and prejudice the jury. "Why do the lyrics have any probative value if it's simply cumulative?" Steel said.
Prosecutors say YSL is responsible for a string of shootings, robberies, and selling drugs. They claim Young Thug, whose real name is Jeffrey William, was the co-founder and leader of the gang, although he denies the charges and says YSL is the acronym of his record label, Young Stoner Life.
The criminal trial has become the longest in Georgia history. Opening statements began last November, 10 months after jury selection with repeated delays and several juror issues. Defense attorneys have urged Glanville to limit the state's anticipated 400 witnesses and to “consider the ramifications of the present pace of trial and its impact on the jury, the case, as well as the defendants.”
The 65-count indictment brought in May 2022 contains 191 “overt acts” that prosecutors contend were carried out in furtherance of the gang.
Many of the acts listed in the indictment involved defendants who are no longer part of the trial, either because they accepted plea deals or have had their cases severed.All six defendants standing trial have been in jail without bond for two years.
https://www.ncja.org/crimeandjusticenews/young-thug-fights-to-exclude-rap-lyrics-from-trial-after-ga-supreme-court-ruling