‘There Is No Balance in This Relationship’: Knesset Debates Israeli Reliance on US Aid
Members of the Israeli Knesset held a session debating Tel Aviv’s reliance on aid from Washington. The US sends Israel at least $3.8 billion in annual military assistance, and in 2024, aid to Israel surged to over $20 billion.
The Knesset members debated with officials and experts about Tel Aviv’s dependence on Washington for weapons and funding to operate its military. “Isn’t it strange that within 24 hours of Oct 7, we were asking for aid from the US? That we couldn’t fight the war on our own? Not three weeks passed and we already had a package of requests for $15 billion of aid?” Gideon Israel, president of the Jerusalem-Washington Center, told the committee.
He continued, “This tendency to beg, where not a moment goes by and we already ask for help from the US is an Israeli quality that has existed for over 50 years … and no one thinks, ‘wait a minute, maybe we need to reevaluate.’”
Dor Shapira, head of the Israeli Foreign Ministry’s North America Bureau, noted, “The fact that we have a partnership with the U.S. doesn’t mean that the sides are even. We get a lot of help in defense and diplomatically, so there is no balance in this relationship.”
In 2016, President Obama signed a Memorandum of Understanding with Israel, promising Tel Aviv $3.8 billion in military aid every year. Following the October 7 attack, assistance to Israel increased to $22 billion.
Gideon Israel explained that “there are no free lunches,” and Washington can use the aid to force Tel Aviv to make certain decisions. However, during Israel’s 15-month-long onslaught in Gaza, the Biden administration refused to leverage military support to Tel Aviv to force Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to halt military operations and allow aid to reach the starving Palestinian people.
Raphael BenLevi, a research fellow at the Misgav Institute for Zionist Strategy and National Security, told the Knesset that US aid has become “part of the central policy considerations of Israel in the last 30 years” but noted that Washington tended to use the aid as a “carrot, not a stick.”
Yoram Ettinger, a former Israeli diplomat, argued that Tel Aviv should reframe the way it discusses US aid. Rather than being grateful to the US for support, Tel Aviv should tell Washington, “No American investment brings in a greater return on investment.”
“We are the flagship store of the American defense industry,” Ettinger said. “When on Oct. 26 [2024] there was an Israeli Air Force operation and 100 American-made planes flew over Iran,” he explained. “This immediately promoted the American industry’s sales. We are a laboratory in battle conditions.”
While Israel’s use of US weapons may present an opportunity to display its capabilities, Tel Aviv’s military operations in Gaza, the West Bank, Lebanon, Syria, Iran, and Yemen created a huge surge in anti-American sentiment in the Middle East.
Former Israeli Deputy National Security Advisor Chuck Freilich, explained that American support for Israel stretches beyond aid, and losing the assistance could jeopardize the wider relationship.
He noted the “diplomatic umbrella” that Tel Aviv receives from Washington. Freilich is likely referring to the US using its veto at the UN Security Council to prevent the body from adopting relations critical of Israel or punishing Tel Aviv for the genocide in Gaza.
He went on to say, “Maybe, but it is a much less safe existence and with much less economic and social welfare. It’s a reality no one wants to return to, the security and economic level of the ‘70s.”
A report by the Israeli outlet Calcalist in October 2024 reviewed Israel’s spending on wars since October 7, 2023, it found that Washington is funding 70% of Tel Aviv’s military costs.
At present, Israel maintains significant influence in Washington. However, younger Americans increasingly view the Palestinians more sympathetically, are against Washington’s support for Tel Aviv, and half believe Israel’s war in Gaza to be a genocide.
https://libertarianinstitute.org/foreign-policy/there-is-no-balance-in-this-relationship-knesset-debates-israeli-reliance-on-us-aid/