LANSING, Mich. (Michigan News Source) – Michigan may be known for its Great Lakes, but it’s also home to plenty of secrets. And if Michiganders want to uncover what their government and school systems are keeping under wraps, they have to file a FOIA request.
The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) is supposed to be a shining beacon of governmental accountability, but lately, it’s looking more like a toll booth with a broken meter. School districts and government bodies across the state are slapping astronomical fees on FOIA requests, ensuring that the only thing citizens get is a lighter wallet and a lesson in futility.
Take Rochester Community Schools, where transparency comes with a price tag that’d make a luxury car blush. At the end of last year, we reported on Elizabeth Clair, a Detroit mom, had dared to ask for public access to public records about the district’s diversity training and materials. She was quoted a fee of more than $33 million. The fee was so ridiculous that it made international news.
Clair isn’t the first one to get a big bill from that school district though. Before her, it was mom Jessica Opfer, who was informed that she’d need to pay over $25 million for her FOIA request for records about the removal of a language arts curriculum.
Then there’s St. Charles, Michigan. Journalist Dave Bondy reports that this school district is charging over $60K for FOIA records regarding school fundraising expenses. That’s a bargain compared to Rochester Schools – but still something the average parent or taxpayer can’t afford.
The district is justifying the cost they quoted to two parents by claiming it’s the result of extensive work at $32 per hour. But let’s do the math: that’s nearly 1,900 hours of labor if no copy charges are incurred – more than an entire year of full-time work. Either they’re hiring a slow-motion scribe, or someone really doesn’t want these numbers seeing the light of day.
Meanwhile, the alleged missing football fundraising money they want to find out about – once safely in the school’s coffers – has mysteriously vanished, much like the school’s willingness to answer questions.
https://www.michigannewssource.com/2025/03/michigan-schools-to-parents-transparency-thatll-be-a-million-bucks-please/