How Snopes Buried the Truth About Ilhan Omar's FatherMar 18, 20251/5Long but Must Read
fact checkers covered up his high-ranking role in a genocidal regime, helping democrats avoid a scandal that could have taken down the squad
For most of the past decade,the misinformation complex— a decentralized, ideologically aligned network of fact-checking sites, media outlets, NGOs, government agencies and social media companies — ruled our information ecosystem. Today, the archives of this ancient régime are being opened. What they show is how,with shockingly little effort, the misinformation complex could shut downinvestigations into even the most clear-cut claims that threatened the Democratic party’s great narratives.
This was precisely the case with= one of the most prominent progressive politicians in the US today, Ilhan Omar==. In 2018, Omar rode a wave of identity politics into high office as representative for Minnesota’s 5th congressional district. The media was not just jubilant but triumphant. Along with the nascent Squad, this Trump-taunting black female politician and former refugee became an instant icon of the new color-bound progressive politics.
But there was a catch: Omar herself would not be shoved into this cardboard cutout of a squeaky clean, infinitely tolerant diversity figure. In her very first weeks in office, she made a series of comments about Israel that fell well within the discourse of antisemitic speech as the Democratic Party itself had long since defined it. Then, far more damagingly, allegations that Omar had married her own brother to secure his visa to the US exploded in the conservative media.
There was,however, another claim that was overshadowed by allegationsof (to coin a term) fratrimony. This was thatOmar’s father had been a “terrorist” or had served the Somali government in a capacity that could have made his entry into the United States illegal. While it didn’t have the tabloid qualities of brother-marriage, if corroborated the story could have been just as damaging.
To be clear, the following does not show, or attempt to show, that Ilhan Omar bears responsibility for decisions made by her father when she was a child.But what it does show is how the fact-checking industry was able to quash a burgeoning political crisiswith just two articles and one threadbare source, and, in doing so,protect Democratic party interests in ways that not even the best, and most expensive, political crisis management agency could even dream of.
On July 25, 2019, Snopes published its assessment of the claim, “Is Rep. Omar’s Father a ‘Somalian War Criminal’ Living ‘Illegally’ in U.S.?”Under a big red triangle featuring an “X” and the text“Mostly False,” the site broke down its finding under three headings. Under the heading “What’s True,” Snopes stated,=“Ilhan Omar’s father is living [sic] the U.S. legally. The family was cleared to enter the country in 1995 and successfully secured asylum status.” Under “What’s False,” Snopes found, “Omar’s father is not in the U.S. illegally.” And marked“What’s undetermined” the site ruled, “Omar’s father was responsible for, or even credibly accused of, any wrongdoing in Somalia.”
In the first sentence of itsfact-check, Snopes reported the various “firsts” Omar had achieved: one of the first two Muslim women elected to Congress, first to “don a religious headscarf,” first Somali-American and naturalized citizen from Africa in Congress. The site then noted that these many “milestones,” however, hadbeen accompanied by “conspiracy theories and racial or religious-themed hoaxes targeting Omar.”
Snopes reported that the claimthat Omar’s father was a Somali war criminal who had come to the US illegally originatedfrom a rightwing blog called Gateway Pundit, which Snopes called a “junk news site.” Gateway Pundit had reported less than a week prior,on July 16, 2019, that Omar’s father, Nur Omar Mohamed, was “connected to the former dictator inSomalia, Said Barre.” Thesite comparedOmar with another Somaliin a similar situation, former Somali NationalArmy colonel,Yusuf Abdi Ali, who was found to havecommitted human rights abuses by a U.S. civil juryin May 2019 and waseventually deportedin 2024 for similar crimes during the same time period.
Gateway Pundit wrote that Omar’s father “and otherSomalians [sic] like YusufAbdi Ali, who killed thousands for Barre, escaped to the West andwere not vettedproperly before entering the country.”
https://www.piratewires.com/p/how-snopes-buried-the-truth-about-ilhan-omar-s-father