dChan - Q Origins Project Archive

Here's a list of major U.S. federal departments that are often cited by constitutional scholars (especially strict constructionists) as lacking explicit constitutional authorization under the original text of the U.S. Constitution.

—

## ⚖️ Federal Departments Commonly Viewed as Unconstitutional (No Explicit Constitutional Authority)

> ⚠️ These departments are not mentioned in the Constitution and are often justified only via broad interpretations of clauses like the Commerce Clause or General Welfare Clause.

### 🚫 Often Challenged Departments:

| Department | Year Established | Reason Often Considered Unconstitutional |

|-------|----|--------–|

| Department of Education | 1979 | Education is a power reserved to the states (10th Amendment). |

| Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) | 1980 (from HEW) | Healthcare and welfare traditionally state responsibilities. |

| Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) | 1965 | Housing policy is not enumerated in the Constitution. |

| Department of Energy | 1977 | Energy regulation not mentioned; seen as state/private domain. |

| Department of Labor | 1913 | Labor regulation seen as overreach via Commerce Clause. |

| Department of Agriculture | 1862 | Farming policy and subsidies lack enumerated authority. |

| Department of Transportation | 1966 | Infrastructure and transit often considered local/state issues. |

| Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) | 1989 | Care for veterans not an enumerated federal function. |

| Department of Homeland Security (DHS) | 2002 | Created post-9/11; critics argue it overlaps or duplicates other constitutional agencies. |

—

## 🛑 Key Constitutional Argument:

> The Tenth Amendment holds that powers not delegated to the federal government are reserved to the states.

So any federal role not enumerated in Article I, Section 8 is considered suspect by strict originalists.

—

## ✅ Constitutionally Grounded Departments (Generally Accepted)

| Department | Reason Considered Constitutional |

|-------|-------|

| Department of State | Foreign policy = delegated power |

| Department of Defense | National defense = enumerated power |

| Department of Treasury | Coin money, manage debts, taxes |

| Department of Justice (DOJ) | Enforces federal laws passed under enumerated powers |

—

>>22946693

Great question — this goes right to the heart of constitutional originalism and the limits of federal power. Here's a list of major U.S. federal departments that are often cited by constitutional scholars (especially strict constructionists) as lacking explicit constitutional authorization under the original text of the U.S. Constitution.