UK Police participation in Pride ruled 'unlawful'
A Northumbria Police car parked in the city centre. It has been decorated in Pride colours and has the words Policing with Pride displayed on its door.
The judicial review does not make a ruling on how Northumbria Police should approach the 2025 event
Jonny Manning
BBC News, North East and Cumbria
Published
16 July 2025
Updated 17 July 2025
A chief constable's decision to allow uniformed police officers to take part in a Pride march was unlawful, a judge has ruled.
A case was brought against Northumbria Police Chief Constable Vanessa Jardine by Linzi Smith, from Newcastle, who is a lesbian who describes herself as "gender critical".
Ms Smith argued Mrs Jardine and her officers' participation in Newcastle Pride last year meant they would have been unable to remain impartial if a dispute between those with similar beliefs and transgender rights supporters, had occurred.
The force said it would work through the ruling to understand the implications but would remain true to its values of "fairness, visibility, and support for all".
In a judgement issued on Wednesday after a High Court hearing in Leeds earlier this month, Mr Justice Linden said Mrs Jardine's decision to allow officers to take part in the event was "outside the range of reasonable decisions open to her".
He said Mrs Jardine appeared to have mistakenly believed her responsibilities under the Equality Act could outweigh her duty to be impartial when, in fact, impartiality was the primary requirement.
Ms Smith said she was "delighted" with the court's judgement, feeling the force had "abandoned their duty of impartiality and embraced a highly controversial political cause".
"Their participation in the Pride march clearly shows where their sympathies lie," she said.
"My hope is Northumbria Police change their ways and follow this ruling. If they do, they will be policing the community for everyone."
Linzi Smith outside of St James' Park. She is wearing a Newcastle United scarf and has short brown hair.
Linzi Smith, who is also known as Lindsey, was banned from St James' Park over comments she made on social media
Ms Smith believes that whether someone is a man or a woman is defined by their biology, not by the gender with which they identify.
Her lawyers told the court she believes the Newcastle Pride takes an opposing position, supporting transgender campaigners and gender ideology.
The court was told a "contingent of uniformed officers" led by the chief constable joined last year's march, some displaying transgender flag colours or holding Police Pride flags, and "marched in the immediate proximity of those carrying the flags and emblems clearly associated with the gender ideologists' cause".
Ms Smith's lawyers argued this breached the force's duty of impartiality.