‘Gen Z Is in the House!’ and Other Cringe Moments in the Democrats’ Shutdown Marathon
pure KEK
Democrats promised to livestream the shutdown battle until (almost) the bitter end. We watched so you didn’t have to.
Adam Wren
I binged more than 14 hours of the occasionally awkward, repetitive — if mostly on message — programming on YouTube (there was also an X stream).But even if it was a physically exhausting and mentally taxing process, it was a revealing window into the Democrats’ larger plight: a struggle to get their message through in an attention economy that prizes watchability and entertainment, making it almost impossible for them to break through the din of President Donald Trump’s neverending newscycle.
“Trump is gonna do something crazy as soon as the go[vernment] shuts down and that’ll be the story,” lamented one House Democratic aide. (I granted anonymity to Democratic and Republican insiders alike so they could speak candidly.)
The party in power historically loses the shutdown.But no party in power has had a leader with a megaphone likeTrump does now.
In launching the livestream, which featured the feel of athrowback telethon with none of the charisma or surprise, Jeffries and his allies seemed to tacitly acknowledge that they needed to be fighting, and sounding and looking as if they were. (“Y’all, I ain’t scared,” Jeffries said at one point. “I’m from Brooklyn.”) But few Dems seemed willing to fight on camera. The livestream featured just four frontline Democrats of 26 in competitive districts — and few of the party’s brightest stars like AOC or Jasmine Crockett — a possible tell that they see some risk here. (Rep. Sarah McBride, the 35-year-old from Delaware, did join briefly at the beginning.) Notably, Democrats could not field live programming for three hours in the middle of the night, from 2:30 a.m. to 5:30 a.m., despite an internal email desperately seeking participants. (A spokesperson for Jeffries declined to comment on the three hours of recorded re-run content). And it showed that while Democrats are clearly listening to a lot of people online urging them to fight, a lot of people online may not be listening to them.
House Democrats also got hit from the left, as the Sen. Bernie Sanders-led livestream of Senate Democrats on the shutdown scored some 90,000 viewers in real time, racking up 357,311 views by Wednesday morning. To be fair, creators clipped the livestream and distributed portions across X and other social media views, some of which drew tens of thousands of views, far more than the livestream itself.
“There are Democrats who are attracting more eyeballs and enthusiasm,” Rebecca Katz, the founding partner at Fight Agency which has produced ads for New York City mayoral contender Zohran Mamdani, told me as she fumed at how few viewers Jeffries was landing. “The problem is party leadership is shunning many of them.”
In a statement to POLITICO Magazine, a spokesperson for Jeffries said his three separate livestreams on X generated over 60,000 views and that “clips from the livestream are continuing to also generate hundreds of thousands of views and we still have more coming.”
“As Leader Jeffries has consistently said and done, Democrats are in a more-is-more environment,” said Christie Stephenson, Jeffries’ spokesperson.“Apparently for some, that means more is more snark and that’s their choice as to how they want to spend this pivotal moment. While Republicans canceled votes, vacationed and fundraised at steakhouses, Democratic Members of Congress, stakeholders and everyday Americans united to define the stakes of the Republican healthcare crisis and the Trump shutdown.”
Here, in excerpts from the livestream, Democrats spent their online air time swapping candy from Hawaii, troubleshooting tech issues and searching for ways to attract attention during the shutdown’s earlier hours.
2 p.m.:Aside from a countdown clock, the walkup to the first government shutdown to be live-streamed — quasi-continuously — isn’t the exciting fare you might think: It’s two guys sitting in leather chairs with microphones.
“Good afternoon, everybody,” says Jeffries, appearing on a livestream in front of a podcast mic, an American flag draped behind him. He was sitting next to Rep. Maxwell Frost (D-Fla.), whom Jeffries hails as “one of the rising stars of the United States Congress.”
https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2025/10/01/democrats-shutdown-livestream-00591178