TYB
The “probable” answer in a Socratic or riddle‑style context is: “A bird sings at dawn.”[1]
## Why “at dawn” is the answer
-
Many songbirds have a strong “dawn chorus,” a peak in singing activity around first light, so “at dawn” matches a real natural pattern.[2][3]
-
In philosophical or cryptic dialogue, dawn symbolizes a moment when things become clear or revealed, so “when does a bird sing?” points to “when the new light comes” or “when truth is about to emerge.”[4][1]
## Socratic-style reasoning behind it
A Socratic questioner would not expect you just to guess; the goal is to lead you through steps like:
-
Clarify the concrete case
-
When are birds most noticeably vocal?
-
Observation leads you to: “Early morning, at first light.”[3][2]
-
Abstract from the observation
-
What does dawn represent besides a time of day?
-
It can represent the beginning of something, or the moment when what was hidden becomes visible.[1][4]
-
Apply the abstraction back to the questioner’s topic
-
In many Socratic or quasi‑Socratic political/religious uses, the question is metaphorical: “When do people reveal the truth / expose corruption / ‘sing’ like a canary?”
-
The implied answer: “They ‘sing’ when a new phase begins, when exposure or awakening (dawn) arrives.”[5][6][1]
So the reasoning path is: empirical observation of birds → recognition of dawn as the key time → recognition of dawn as a metaphor for revelation or awakening → answer “at dawn,” carrying both the literal and symbolic meanings.