From Sde Teiman, the truth about Israel’s military justice system has been set free
By dropping all charges against the soldiers filmed abusing a Palestinian detainee, Israel has abandoned the whole masquerade of accountability.
The renowned astrophysicist Stephen Hawking discovered that a black hole, the celestial object that swallows everything around it and from which, seemingly, nothing that enters ever escapes, nevertheless emits a certain level of electromagnetic radiation. As is customary in the exact sciences, the phenomenon was named after the scientist who discovered it; in this case, “Hawking radiation.”
Sde Teiman, the Israeli military base-turned-detention facility for Palestinians, which includes a hospital compound for prisoners, has functioned since early on in Israel’s devastating war on Gaza as a moral black hole. All traces of humanity — be it the most basic moral principles, medical ethics, or any remnants of Israeli shame — were swallowed up into it and completely disappeared.
According to testimonies from former detainees and investigations by journalists and human rights organizations, we Israelis starved, tortured, and humiliated Palestinian prisoners there, while providing the wounded and sick with disgraceful medical treatment which, on several occasions, led to amputations that would have been avoidable had the care been reasonable. All values were whirled into the heart of the moral black hole that is the Sde Teiman camp. Was no value at all really saved from it?
Well, it turns out that Sde Teiman, too, has its own Hawking radiation spewing out of it. But just like what disappeared into Sde Teiman, so too the radiation emitted from it is not electromagnetic but ethical: Sde Teiman has radiated the truth about the nature, functioning, and mission of the law enforcement bodies responsible for handling allegations of Israel’s human rights abuses against Palestinians.
Last week, Israel’s top military lawyer dropped all charges against five soldiers from Force 100 who were accused of beating a Palestinian detainee and tearing his rectum by stabbing it with a sharp object — an act that was partially caught on CCTV camera in footage that was later leaked. In doing so, he exposed once and for all the great Israeli lie about the existence of a professional, independent investigative and prosecutorial system seeking substantively to hold rogue soldiers to account.
The closing of the case and the cancellation of the indictment accusing the defendants of horrific physical abuse of a helpless detainee freed the truth from the chains of lies in which it has been held by Israel’s hasbara apparatus. (Incidentally, this is the proper use of the Hebrew root ḥ-l-tz, “to extract” — not the Israeli who got stuck in London and found a flight back to the land of wars, apartheid, and a Kahanist government, but a terrible truth imprisoned in hell and brought into the light.)
The truth is that a law enforcement system that genuinely strives to hold soldiers accountable when they kill, humiliate, or abuse Palestinians has never existed in Israel, or at least not for several decades. The truth is that what exists is a system that effectively provides immunity for soldiers when their victims are Palestinians, and even strives for that outcome. And the truth is that the rare instances of accountability that the system does produce are intended to conceal this reality and fend off the claim that there is no punishment in Israel for harming Palestinians.
In other words, the military enforcement systems have long wanted to proceed without enforcement, while still appearing as though they were fulfilling their purpose, by sacrificing a few cases, usually minor ones, in which indictments were filed. These indictments were never meant to enforce the law but rather to serve as a symbolic performance of enforcement — an exception designed to obscure the rule.
According to data obtained through freedom of information requests to the army by the Israeli human rights organization Yesh Din (for which I serve as a legal advisor), between 2016 and 2024 the military enforcement authorities were informed of 2,427 complaints regarding harm to Palestinians by soldiers in the occupied West Bank. The army opened investigations into only 552 of these cases (22.7 percent of the complaints), and only 23 led to indictments (0.9 percent).
In the Gaza Strip, the situation is not much better: More than 1,500 complaints related to soldiers’ conduct since October 2023 have so far yielded only two indictments.
This is the context in which Military Advocate General Itay Offir’s decision to close the Sde Teiman abuse case should be understood: not as a final nail in the coffin of the pretense of law enforcement, but rather as the abandonment of the whole masquerade.
https://www.972mag.com/sde-teiman-israel-military-justice-system/