McCarthyism 2.0: Real skill of US ‘disinformation experts’ is spreading disinformation
An obscure bloggers hit-job on an American writer and his associates amounts to small beans. In the bigger picture, however, it exposes a cancer spreading through present American discourse on Russia and the wider world.
MOSCOW – Once again it was Molly McKew. “Putin is waging an information assault on Americans – yet many supposedly anti-Putin experts want you to believe there's nothing you can do to stop it,” she tweeted. “Why? Stellar wknd (sic) longread by @JamesFourM (Jay McKenzie) on understanding how the Kremlin takes down its critics.”
And with that, a group of American thinkers and writers with no obvious sympathies towards Russia, had their reputations attacked.. Some days later, Medium, which hosted the smear, took the piece down – but the damage had been done.
Now, you’d need a heart of stone to take satisfaction from the current Russia hysteria in the United States. Because it’s genuinely sad to see the political and media elite of a great country tear themselves apart over poltergeists that most rational people assumed had evaporated decades ago.
What’s even more depressing is how the social media age, which promised a new dawn in expression and thought, is increasingly echoing the worst excesses of the 1950s: the period known as “McCarthyism.”
Except the new smear artists are arguably even more uncouth and opportunistic than their predecessors from those two-tone times. And they have less justification: Russia is no longer a closed country, hidden behind an “iron curtain.” In fact, contemporary Americans, if they so desire, can pick up a visa and bounce around from St. Petersburg to Vladivostok to their heart’s content.
Fool's gold
However, the spy hunters and “disinformation warriors” aren’t interested in first-hand experience, because their real motivation is to smear and silence the genuinely curious, who have invested the time and effort to acquire expertise. And what’s thoroughly depressing is that Molly McKew, John Schindler, Eric Garland, and their fellow travelers boast tremendous influence on Twitter and many also have platforms on mainstream media.
McKew, for instance, is a Politico columnist, who appears on US national television and is frequently cited as an “expert” by the Washington Post. A paper which also publishes Max Boot. Indeed, only last week, he used its pages to ludicrously claim Trump couldn’t have won the 2016 US election without Russian assistance. And, no, Boot didn’t suggest Moscow had somehow convinced Hillary Clinton not to campaign in Wisconsin. Meanwhile, Schindler is a familiar face to Fox and CNN viewers.
Last weekend presented a vivid example of how these charlatans operate, when they used their Twitter accounts to promote a – subsequently deleted – “Medium” post designed to defame Dustin Giebel, an American writer who focuses on Russia. The diatribe, from one Jay McKenzie, appeared to be alleging that Giebel was some sort of Kremlin agent because he’d regarded the poet Yevgeny Yevtushenko as a mentor at college. Yevtushenko, who died last year, had been a supporter of reformist Soviet and Russian leaders Mikhail Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin, who late-in-life, divided his time between Russia and the United States.
While the “gotcha” nonsense largely focused on attempting to trip up Giebel over old tweets (obviously uninterested in Edward de Bono’s observation: “If you never change your mind, why have one.”), it also took aim at buddies, online at least, of the writer. Thus, Nina Jankowicz, a think-tanker at the US government-funded Wilson Center, and Michael Colborne, a Canadian journalist hardly noted for Kremlin sympathies, ended up in the crossfire.
And it all seemed to be inspired by the shocking revelation that Giebel intended to take his wife to Moscow this June, during the World Cup, which was taken as clear evidence of his comprised credentials. Giebel later alleged that the fallout led to a “threat against my two-year-old daughter from one of your loony’s (sic) so your cosplay and doxxing was a success. Thank Molly McKew and John for this, the great AMERICAN threat is sleeping with her blankie.”
Sad times
He was referring to how McKew and former CIA agent turned TV fixture John Sipher had shared the smear job. And they were joined by Moscow-born neoconservative activist Max Boot.
1/2