Ex-CIA operative Plame: 'It's not inconceivable' Paul Whelan is a spy
Paul Whelan of Novi, held in a czarist-era Russian prison on spy charges, would attract the notice of any seasoned intelligence team, a former CIA covert operations officer told the Free Press. "As long as there are nation-states, there will be espionage. It is a very real threat and even more so today," said retired officer Valerie Plame, now an author who was famously outed as a CIA operative during the second Bush administration.
Whelan, 48, an executive with the auto parts manufacturer BorgWarner in Auburn Hills, was picked up by Russian authorities on Dec. 28 on suspicion of spying. His twin brother said the ex-Marine, whose military record included a larceny conviction, was in Russia for a friend's wedding. The Russians indicted Whelan on Thursday. No one knows what about the Russians' assertion is true except, perhaps, U.S. government officials, who have said little about the case and likely have access to information they have not revealed, Plame suggested. Is it possible Whalen could be a spy? "It is not inconceivable," Plame said. She noted, "There are many Americans that seek to serve their country in various ways. That's probably all I should say."
Other former CIA operatives and scholars of espionage, though, say it's most likely Whelan is being framed by Russian President Vladimir Putin for political reasons, a scenario Plame did not discount. They also agree that Whalen's story has eyebrow-raising and contradictory oddities. He had traveled regularly to Russia since about 2006 and had a Russian social media account through which he connected with members of the country's military, but lacked strong command of the language, the New York Times reported. On Friday, Ireland’s Department of Foreign Affairs said Whelan had asked for help as an Irish citizen, and officials confirmed he is a U.S., British and Irish citizen.
"There do seem to be real question marks around this story, at least in the public domain," Plame said Thursday. "That he was discharged from the military, from the Marines, dishonorably. That he's got this big interest in Russia; he travels there a lot. Huh? He's an auto parts guy? Really? I don't know. He could be completely innocent. The Kremlin could be trying to be provocative. Or there could be something there." His brother, David, a resident of Ontario, said in a Washington Post op-ed piece that the family was surprised to learn of Paul's dishonorable discharge from the Marines and, "As for his international connections, our family spans continents, and Paul’s four passports reflect his birth (Canada), parents (Britain), grandparents (Ireland) and choice (United States)."
https://www.freep.com/story/news/2019/01/03/cia-whelan-russia-american-held-spy/2469240002/