Anonymous ID: 245f2e Jan. 23, 2019, 2:28 p.m. No.4878613   🗄️.is đź”—kun   >>8715 >>8925 >>9043 >>9112

>>4878479

If you look at what's being challenged, it's not really a 2nd Amendment case, but a commerce case. NYC is essentially saying "you can't take this legal item that you bought legally here in the city outside of the city limits".

The City has no such power; NY State might have such power to deny entry into the rest of the State if such an item were illegal (think something else, like drugs, rather than guns), just as a bordering State can arrest you for transporting items into their jurisdiction that are illegal. (State lines would of course fall under Federal Jurisdiction too under interstate commerce.)

So the fact it's guns is kinda irrelevant, and should be a 9-0 smackdown. But because it's guns, it puts the Liberals on the court in a bit of a pickle…