Agree with you, personally.
But if one things is true, then that for Q it'd be easy to confirm/dismiss it. I myself, as a clockfag privately, would not care if the current model/hypothesis of the clock is right or wrong. I'd just think again and try the next most likely model/idea.
Instead Q observes what's going on and the amount of shilling, all while I know that the original clockfags are genuine and honest, and far from shills.
So there must be a reason, evidently, Q never comment on the clock …