Anonymous ID: 8ce936 April 20, 2019, 7:21 p.m. No.6258587   🗄️.is 🔗kun

>>6258521

Here's the Catholic take:

 

There are 3 conditions to be culpable for a mortal sin (damned into hell). All 3 must be met

  1. it must be serious sin (mortal), so stealing a pack of gum is not; but suicide is.

  2. You must know it is a serious sin - if you didn't know, then not culpable

  3. Full consent of the will - you chose to do it anyways without coercion.

 

Both 2 and 3 look pretty darn iffy in this case due to meds, mental illness etc. In fact i think most suicides seem iffy for the very reason it would take almost mental illness to do it.