Holy shit
You just perfectly described the fall of Satan myth.
Perhaps Plato and Aristotle both didn't even exist and are just a personification of the deeper knowledge of idealism vs realism.
Of course it's likely Aristotle did exist as he was the tutor of motherfucking Alexander the Great
This OP claim really makes me wonder about Alexander all the sudden.
If any of you supposed plus ultra folk are lurking I would love you to add your thoughts!