>> 9803905 (pb)

>>9802859 (pb)

Response from organic geochemist spouseanon:

In brief, all oil evaporates (becomes gas) at 200C; therefore, this "theory" that oil can be generated at 1500C is absurd.

In addition, oil consists of organic molecules that cannot be the result of polymerization of inorganic methane.

In summary, these articles are not scientific but read like the work of snake oil salesmen.

Do a reality-check: No oil is found anywhere on earth in the mountains or the mid-oceanic ridge where the mantle exhumes at the earth's surface. Oil is always found in the sedimentary basin where organic-rich source rocks are present.