which eye should I look him straight into it?
you might want to say 'look me straight in the eyes'.
i know I mispell a lot and give away drafts (so it's not so easy to steal ) but in a meme you have to get the grammer and spelling correct, and that doesn't always mean proper grammar and spelling, however, in this case if you put in an 's' you have a meme that challanges.
otherwise you just give out an opportunity for a snarky-response, and then a dismissal of you for having shown a lame meme.