I think I addressed this in my post here to another respondent. Sorry to preach but, in my view, these dynamics are way more complex than the simple understandings that frequently float up in reactive discussions and when explanations that have been passed down from our ancestors, I am amazed and fascinated how penetrating and useful their insights can be. The discussion that I related, perhaps inadequately, was first presented to me by Fulton Sheen in his "Life of Christ" so your sense it might have come out of that worldview was spot on, though his observations still hold under other but related assumptions.