>>14074460

That's not really true in music. Machines can program memorable music with rhythmic dissonance and euclidean rhythms mixed with a few simple statements about how melodies should be constructed. Music is math at the end of the day, even the dumbest drummer is dividing rhythms, and every instrument's very structure is based on even division and the golden ratio so even the most ignorant musician can have their performance broken down to math.

The more true statement for this situation is you can't make anything memorable without skill.

>>14074581

Nah, catchy melodies are as simple as even divisions, harmonic dissonance, and cyclical melodies. Take it from someone who writes catchy melodies. Soul doesn't even exist to be quite honest with you, you're confusing soul with skill.

>>14074630

>argument using technical terms to clearly define the argument and point out flaws

<argument from authority

Pick one and only one.

>>14074635

>implying you can't create an equation for memorable music

I'm sorry, do you make music?

>>14074635

And I really can't stop myself from double posting here: You do realize that the scales on which modern music is built are, themselves, an equation for memorable music… right?

>>14074646

>>14074649

>I don't make music, but I know everything about it

Music fans are the worst. Think they know everything and are passionate but really they don't know shit and are arguing from a point of ignorance.

>>14074656

<can't argue the point

<time to meme it up!

>>14074671

I'm sorry, I'm pretty sure I made my arguments, let me go over them for you again since clearly you're too ass blasted to acknowledge them, in fact let me recap this whole conversation for you:

>Machines can program memorable music with rhythmic dissonance and euclidean rhythms mixed with a few simple statements about how melodies should be constructed.

>Music is math at the end of the day, even the dumbest drummer is dividing rhythms, and every instrument's very structure is based on even division and the golden ratio so even the most ignorant musician can have their performance broken down to math.

<muh lifeless muh soul muh buzzwords

>catchy melodies are as simple as even

divisions, harmonic dissonance, and cyclical melodies.

<durr you can't create an equation for memorable melodies

>You do realize that the scales on which modern music is built are, themselves, an equation for memorable music… right?

<LOL YOU POSTED TWICE!!!!

>implying that's the same argument again and again

>implying muh soul isn't the same argument again and again

Enjoy talking from a source of absolute ignorance and acting smug about it

>>14074687

At this point I won't be posting anything in this thread because I'm sure ass blasted autistic faggots will shit on it regardless. At the end of the day I'm not making my argument from authority and if that's all you can see then you're not reading my whole posts or are retarded.

>>14074708

>being an ass blasted faggot

>>14074720

>he has to reply to my every post with angry green text

>but he's not angry

You're TOTALLY not mad, how could I be so confused. I mean I came in here and to you how and why you were wrong with technical terms and information and you then totally didn't throw a fit. I mean I don't know how I could be so confused.

Also:

>implying making music is rare or hard and that everyone and their mother doesn't have a soundcloud page

It's been fun anon, but I only have so much time to argue with music autists who think they know everything when they don't even understand what a scale is. This will be your last (you) from me, but keep in touch.