SILICON VALLEY COMMUNITY FOUNDATION ISA COMMUNITY CATALYST FOR POSITIVE CHANGE. WE PARTNER WITH DONORS, BUSINESSES, GOVERNMENTS AND (CONTINUED ON SCHEDULE O)
The Silicon Valley Community Foundation (SVCF) is a left-of-center grantmaking organization with over $11 billion in assets. The Foundation conducts most of its grantmaking through donor-advised fund (DAF) accounts established with oversight from individual donors who can advise how their gifts are distributed for charitable purposes.
SVCF has drawn criticism in recent years as a “Black Hole” for charitable donations because IRS rules and SVCF practice have allowed money to be held in DAF accounts for years with no required minimum payouts to charitable organizations (as are required of private foundations). [1] This allows donors to receive large tax breaks immediately, before the donations benefit charitable causes.
SVCF was rocked by scandal in 2018 when its largest fundraiser, Mari Ellen Loijens, resigned amidst dozens of allegations of abusive management and sexual harassment. An independent investigation by the law firm Boies Schiller Flexner found a number of the allegations “were substantiated,” leading to the ouster of former CEO Emmet Carson following an independent investigation. [2]
Donors to SVCF
SVCF is highly dependent upon substantial donations from a relatively small number of ultra-wealthy donors. According to its 2019 annual report, SVCF received 70 percent of its contributions from 11 donors; in 2018, 75 percent of its contributions came from just 10 donors, up from 69 percent of all contributions from 11 donors in 2017. [84] [85]
As of May 2018, at least 17 billionaires had donated to SVCF, including high-profile, left-of-center donors. [86] Most donors placed shares of stock into donor-advised funds (DAFs), allowing the donors to benefit from upfront tax benefits and the power to advise the disbursement of their donations. [87]
Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg gave the largest donation to SVCF, amounting to $1.75 billion in Facebook stock in 2010. [88] In 2018, he gave an additional donation of $200 million. [89]
Most of the other billionaire donors are Silicon Valley CEOs or founders of companies, including WhatsApp cofounder Brian Acton, Twitter founder and CEO Jack Dorsey, and notable left-of-center donor and Netflix co-founder Reed Hastings. [90] Howard Schultz, the Starbucks chairman who explored a presidential campaign as an independent in 2019, also gave to SVCF. [91]
Grants from SVCF
In spite of its purpose as a grantmaking organization, SVCF disbursed just $1.8 billion in grants in 2017, just over 14 percent of its total assets. [92] That same year, SVCF assets increased from just $5.3 billion to $13.5 billion, surpassing the assets of the Ford Foundation. [93] Though SVCF is not required to publicly disclose specific asset sources, the increase likely came from the appreciation of SVCF investments, which include potentially 36 million Facebook shares, donated by founder Mark Zuckerberg. [94]
References
Semuels, Alana. “The ‘Black Hole’ That Sucks Up Silicon Valley’s Money.” The Atlantic.
Atlantic Media Company, May 18, 2018. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/05/silicon-valley-community-foundation-philanthropy/560216/. ^
“Update from Silicon Valley Community Foundation Board of Directors.” Silicon Valley Community Foundation, June 27, 2018. https://www.siliconvalleycf.org/blog/announcements/update-silicon-valley-community-foundation-board-directors. ^
Woolfolk, John. “Warehousing Tech Elite’s Wealth? New Path Urged for Silicon Valley Charity.” The Mercury News. The Mercury News, August 1, 2018. https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/08/01/warhousing-tech-elites-wealth-new-path-urged-for-silicon-valley-charity/. ^
Schleifer, Theodore. “Today’s ‘Working Robber Barons’ Have Used a Tax Break to Create a $110 Billion Charity Stockpile That Isn’t Getting Any Smaller.” Vox. Vox, July 2, 2019. https://www.vox.com/recode/2019/7/2/18691693/silicon-valley-donor-advised-funds-fidelity-charitable-lawsuit. ^
Pender, Kathleen. “Silicon Valley Community Foundation’s Assets Surged in 2017. It Won’t Say Why.” SFChronicle.com. San Francisco Chronicle, February 24, 2018. https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/networth/article/Silicon-Valley-Community-Foundation-s-assets-12704936.php. ^
https://www.shalomdc.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Jfed-Pub-insspection-990-6_30_15.pdf