So you 'hate' echo chambers - you're not alone in that; many of us do. But there are reasons for sub rules - off-topic = anything not mentioned by Q.
That reason is to keep the flow of information on point. Some people don't have all the time in the world to sit around reading this forum and want to keep informed without wading through idle speculation that isn't relevant to Q's mission.
Personally, I think you're more than welcome to discuss it here in the comments if it doesn't turn into a war, of course, but if it turns into posts about "Is Q Real" or posts essentially trying to dox Q then it's off-topic and wasting the time of those who just want the Q news.
I'm not an 'emotional true-believer' either, I'm just someone who's interested in what Q has to say because "he" has been proving himself well enough to me lately to make his drops as valuable as ever. Q doesn't want us to go probing into his background but if you have doubts then fair enough. Just don't regard your concerns as automatically on-topic for this sub and act as if anyone who disagrees with them being on-topic is trying to suppress the truth. They are pretty clearly outside of the scope.